I’ve been having a conversation (as we have conversations nowadays – through email) with a certain prominent local Republican about Republicanism and whether or not I would consider myself a Republican. I assume this fellow is going through the same sort of political identity crisis I went through (am still going through?) not so long ago. So, it brings up the question: What is a Republican? And how many Republicans are really Republican?
There was a time when I would have answered the question “Are you a Republican?” with a resounding “YES!” I was raised thinking that there were only two options in politics (and I’ve been interested in politics for longer than is probably healthy – I think I started paying attention to such things as soon as I started reading the newspaper. At age 6. Not kidding.) In my world, you were either a Republican or a Democrat. Republicans stood for lower taxes, less spending, and a weaker central government. Democrats wanted to tax you silly, spend the country into oblivion, and increase the power of the Federal Government until you had to have Congressional permission to pee. Sounds simple, right?
As I’ve become more involved in government and politics, however, I have learned that things aren’t quite so simple. Power corrupts. Even Republicans are corrupted by power and the desire to be in office. This has led to fewer and fewer members of government who actually care about what they stand for. They pander. They do what it takes to get reelected. They tell us what we want to hear. “Republican” doesn’t mean what I thought it meant.
In their purest forms (in all seriousness – no more cracking on the Democrats), our two political parties represent two different ideals on the best way to run a nation. The Democrats - ideally – favor a pure Democracy, i.e., everybody votes, everybody has a say, and the Federal Government keeps everything in check. They would favor a strong Central Government over states’ rights. This would be the party of Alexander Hamilton.
The Republicans on the other hand – ideally - favor a Republican form of government. The Central government prints money and acts as the “glue” that holds the states together, while states’ rights are favored over absolute Federal power. This would be the party of Thomas Jefferson.
Based on these ideals, I would be a Republican. Whole-hog, through and through, I would wear the Republican banner proudly. But this is not what the Republicans or the Democrats stand for anymore. When did the parties stray so far from their ideals? I’m not sure, but it was well before Abraham Lincoln invaded his own country “for the good of the Union” (someone should have told him that the Constitution made membership in the Union voluntary, so the states had every right to secede. But I digress.)
The fact is that the pure opposition parties of Thomas Jefferson and Alexander Hamilton don’t exist anymore. The clear dispute between the Federalists and the Democratic-Republicans has become muddled, corrupted, and altogether unidentifiable.
What we have now in the United States is two sides of the same coin – two parties who believe in the same sort of governmental power, but who are beholden to different special interests. Sure, there are those in each party who could truly be called “Hamiltonian” or “Jeffersonian,” but those are few and far between.
More often than not I am going to agree with a Republican over a Democrat, but can I call myself a Republican? Not really. Sadly (or maybe not so sadly) this is the state of many members of my generation – those of us in our 20′s and 30′s who, for whatever reason, have associated ourselves with the Republican party. I think most of us believe (or at one time believed) that we were signing up for some sort of “Jeffersonian” ideal, only to find out later that we’ve bought an entirely different thing altogether. So we have this crisis. And a lot of us are moving toward Libertarianism.
Could I call myself a Libertarian? Maybe. But I’m being a lot more careful about sticking a label on myself nowadays, because it just might come back to haunt me later…