When my mother (who has Parkinson’s Disease) called me last night to tell me about Rush Limbaugh’s comments about Michael J. Fox’s campaign ads, I opted not to rush to judgment. Rush Limbaugh has said some ridiculous things in his day, but I thought it best to get the facts before flying off the handle. So, after reading numerous news stories this morning, here’s my take:
In case you haven’t heard about the ads, Michael J. Fox, who suffers from Parkinson’s Disease, has done several TV commercials and made appearances for Democratic candidates who support embryonic stem cell research. In the ads, his symptoms are obvious and difficult to watch. He shakes, rocks, and, like any Parkinson’s sufferer, has a hard time controlling his movements. In his spot for Missouri Senate candidate, Claire McCaskill, he then says, “What you do in Missouri matters to millions of Americans. Americans like me.” Fox has done similar ads for Rep. Benjamin L. Cardin, who is running for the Senate in Maryland, and Wisconsin Gov. Jim Doyle.
On the one hand, Michael J. Fox is using his celebrity to draw attention to a horrible, debilitating disease, and I admire him for that. Instead of hiding away, embarrassed by his awkward movements, he is placing himself in the spotlight to try and help millions of people who don’t have the luxury of money and fame.
However, as Limbaugh said yesterday, to give Parkinson’s sufferers the idea that if you vote for a particular candidate you will be cured is disgusting. My mom said last night that those with Parkinson’s will grasp on to any straw of hope that there might – just maybe – be some sort of cure out there. Fox, through these ads, is giving Parkinson’s sufferers a straw of hope that there may be a cure…if only they vote for McCaskill/Doyle/Cardin. That makes me very uncomfortable.
Now, for Limbaugh’s comments. He did say, “I don’t care what anybody says; it is unseemly, it is exploitative, and it is downright mean to mislead people who suffer from horrible diseases that there is a cure around the corner — if only Republicans could be defeated.” There, I agree.
Limbaugh also said, “He is exaggerating the effects of the disease. He’s moving all around and shaking and it’s purely an act. . . . This is really shameless of Michael J. Fox. Either he didn’t take his medication or he’s acting.” Now, there I take issue. To accuse someone of faking a disease is serious business, and it’s an accusation that no one should ever, ever make without significant evidence. Fox’s appearances on “Boston Legal” in recent months are an indication that there are times that he can medicate and control his movements to an extent, but, as someone who has close, personal contact with a Parkinson’s sufferer on a very regular basis, I can attest to the fact that there are good days and bad days; days when the medication helps and days when it doesn’t. It is nearly impossible to control the movements association with Parkinson’s, for, the more one tries to control them, the worse the movements become.
Fox has reportedly admitted to using his symptoms to make a point, either by limiting his medication or by not making any effort to suppress his movements (however futile those efforts may be); however, I don’t have a problem with this. He shows the disease for what it is – what it would be without medication – and what it is for millions of patients who don’t get the help from the medication that he does. Whether or not he actually exaggerates his movements, only Fox knows, and it is certainly not anyone’s place to accuse him of doing so – no matter how angry you might be about his politicizing his illness.